Question: How do MySQL and PostgreSQL compare in terms of high availability?

Answer

High availability (HA) is crucial for database systems, especially in environments where downtime can lead to significant losses. Both MySQL and PostgreSQL offer robust solutions for high availability, but they differ in their approaches and implementations.

MySQL High Availability

MySQL provides several options for achieving high availability:

  1. Replication: This is the most common approach used in MySQL for HA. MySQL supports asynchronous replication, where data is copied from a primary server to one or more secondary servers. Semi-synchronous replication is also supported, which ensures at least one secondary server has received the data before the transaction commits.

  2. MySQL Cluster: This is a technology that enables clustering of in-memory databases in a shared-nothing system. The MySQL Cluster automatically shards the data across nodes, making it highly available and fault-tolerant.

  3. Group Replication: Introduced in MySQL 5.7, this provides a native solution for creating fault-tolerant systems with multiple masters in a group. It uses distributed state machine replication to synchronize data among servers.

  4. Orchestrator: An open-source tool that manages MySQL topology and helps automate failover and recovery operations.

Example of setting up basic replication in MySQL:

-- On the master: CHANGE MASTER TO MASTER_HOST='master_host_name', MASTER_USER='replication_user', MASTER_PASSWORD='password'; -- On the slave: START SLAVE;

PostgreSQL High Availability

PostgreSQL also offers a variety of options for ensuring high availability:

  1. Streaming Replication: This allows a standby server to stay up-to-date with the primary server by streaming WAL (Write-Ahead Logging) records as they are generated, without waiting for the logs to be written to disk.

  2. Logical Replication: Introduced in PostgreSQL 10, this feature allows users to replicate data at a more granular level than whole database replication. It supports replication sets, selective table replication, and filtering.

  3. Hot Standby: This feature allows the standby server to handle read-only queries while the primary server handles all write operations, effectively distributing the load.

  4. Patroni: A popular open-source tool that automates the setup and maintenance of PostgreSQL HA clusters using streaming replication. It handles failover and automatic configuration changes.

Example of configuring streaming replication in PostgreSQL:

-- On the primary: CREATE ROLE replica LOGIN REPLICATION ENCRYPTED PASSWORD 'secret'; -- Configure primary server settings and restart -- On the standby: pg_basebackup -h primary_host -D /var/lib/postgresql/data -U replica -P -- Configure standby server settings and start the server

Conclusion

Both MySQL and PostgreSQL have strong and versatile features to support high availability. The choice between them often depends on specific project requirements, personal or team familiarity, and the existing infrastructure. MySQL tends to be preferred in environments where read scalability is crucial, while PostgreSQL is favored for its advanced features and flexibility in transactional systems.

Was this content helpful?

White Paper

Free System Design on AWS E-Book

Download this early release of O'Reilly's latest cloud infrastructure e-book: System Design on AWS.

Free System Design on AWS E-Book
Start building today

Dragonfly is fully compatible with the Redis ecosystem and requires no code changes to implement.